Sale: 20% off everything through Dec 1
Wine Country Woodworks

Alumilite vs. Epoxy for Pen Blanks (and How to Beat Resin Moisture Problems)

By Casey Martin · Updated

Video: Does "Cheap” Epoxy Resin From Amazon Work for Woodturning? Let's Find out!
Does "Cheap” Epoxy Resin From Amazon Work for Woodturning? Let's Find out!

I cast almost everything in Alumilite, which goes under pressure. I wanted to know if the cheap epoxy on Amazon would work for turning, so I bought three of the cheapest epoxies I could find with Prime shipping. Then I cast them and turned them on the lathe.

This guide covers what I found in that Alumilite vs. epoxy test, how I cast pen blanks so they come out clear and strong, and the moisture problems that cause most of the bubbles and milky lines I get sent pictures of. By the end you'll know which resin to pick for turning, how to dry your wood so it doesn't ruin a cast, and what to watch for on the lathe.

Video: Does "Cheap” Epoxy Resin From Amazon Work for Woodturning? Let's Find out!
Does "Cheap” Epoxy Resin From Amazon Work for Woodturning? Let's Find out!

What you need

  • A resin made to be turned. I use Alumilite Clear, which is mixed by weight and cured under pressure. The three Amazon epoxies I tested (East Coast Resin, Art 'n Glow and EasyCast) are mixed by volume.
  • A pressure pot if you're casting a pressure resin like Alumilite. Pressure is what gets rid of the bubbles and makes it crystal clear.
  • A scale for weighing Alumilite, and mixing cups and stir sticks.
  • Molds. HDPE molds and an HDPE mold rack. Silicone works too, but see the warning about cheap epoxy below.
  • Colorants. Mica or pearlescent powders (I used Caster's Choice white pearl and paradise blue in the test) and dye if you want a solid, opaque color.
  • A toaster oven to dry wood before you cast it, if you're making hybrid blanks.
  • Sandpaper, for scuffing a cured blank if you need to top it up.

Alumilite vs. epoxy: what my test showed

All three Amazon epoxies are sold as fine to use without pressure, meaning they're supposed to cure without bubbles on their own. To check that, I poured one batch of each under pressure and one batch left out on the bench. Here's how it went:

Alumilite (what I use)Cheap Amazon epoxy
How it's measuredBy weightBy volume
MixingMix until clearMix until clear; all three were very thick and took real effort to stir
Without pressureNeeds pressureBubbles everywhere, and two of them stuck so badly they tore my silicone mold
Under pressureClearLooked great coming out, but they take 24 hours to fully cure under pressure
Releasing from HDPEEasyEasy, just like Alumilite
On the latheStrongMore brittle, got hot, went out of round without tailstock support, and one piece broke off

They did look good once they were buffed. I've always thought you can take any resin and turn it into something pretty. But they're not made to be turned. Of the three, the EasyCast (red) turned out best and the East Coast Resin (blue) was one of the better ones. But I don't recommend any of them for turning. As a bottle opener, I think you'd snap it in half on the first bottle.

So for turning, I stick with Alumilite under pressure. It's stronger, and it comes out clear.

Step by step: casting pen blanks that turn well

  1. Dry your wood first (hybrid blanks). Moisture is the number one cause of bubbles around the wood. Do this even if the wood is stabilized.
    • Stabilized wood: I put it in the toaster oven at 200°F for about 15 to 20 minutes. I've never had a moisture problem after that. You can go longer if you want to be extra safe.
    • Wood I haven't stabilized (for me that's only really dense hardwoods, like some of the Australian burls): 30 to 40 minutes or even longer. I'll put it in when I have something else to do that takes a while.
    • Don't wait for it to cool. The wood cools down plenty in the five minutes or so it takes to mix and pour, and I've never had warm wood cause a problem. If it sits too long, it pulls moisture back in from the air and you're starting over.
  2. Measure the right way for your resin. Alumilite goes by weight. The epoxies I tested go by volume. With the epoxy kits I just poured each whole bottle in.
  3. Mix until it's clear. Keep stirring until there's no cloudiness and no striations (strings or lines of unmixed resin). If you're casting without pressure, don't stir as hard as I do. Whipping it in adds bubbles that pressure would normally take care of.
  4. Add color, and time your swirls.
    • Swirls bleed together less when the resin is closest to curing. Normal Alumilite Clear has a seven-minute open time, so pouring a swirl at about six minutes, or 6:30 if you can push it, is best. Pour red and blue right after mixing and you're much more likely to get purple.
    • Check transparency before you pour. A color that looks solid in the cup can be see-through once it's turned thin at the ends of a pen. Look at the thin film that creeps up the sides of the cup. If it looks see-through there, it will be on the pen too, so add more dye.
    • Pearlescent powders with no dye will almost always come out somewhat transparent. Add some dye if you don't want that look.
  5. Pour into HDPE. Cured resin pops right off it. In the epoxy test, the blanks in my HDPE molds popped out as easily as Alumilite does. I also made my mold rack from HDPE after trying wood and then melamine, and spills just pop right off.
  6. Get it under pressure in time. Not getting a pressure resin into the pot in time is one of the things that causes bubbles. Without pressure, the epoxies in my test came out with bubbles all over the sides. Vacuum might work, but I've heard it can make some epoxy boil, so I'd be careful.
  7. Demold and check the size. If a solid-color Alumilite blank comes out a little under 3/4 inch, you can pour more Alumilite on top of it. Scuff the cured resin with sandpaper first. The first time I skipped that, the new layer peeled off on the lathe. With the sandpaper trick (which I learned from Zac Higgins), I haven't had it happen since.
  8. Turn with support and watch the heat. Every one of the cheap epoxies turned fine while the tailstock was holding it. Once I took the tailstock off, they went out of round, got hot, and one let go of its glued-in thread insert. I sanded to 600 like I normally would, and that's when the problems started. Looking back, I should have kept the tailstock on for the whole sanding and finishing process. If you do turn a weak resin, keep it supported and watch the heat.
Video: Moisture Problems with Resin Casting (Alumilite, Epoxy, Polyester, Etc.)
Moisture Problems with Resin Casting (Alumilite, Epoxy, Polyester, Etc.)

Common problems and fixes

Milky line where the resin meets the wood

That's moisture. Sometimes it's so bad it turns foamy. Dry the wood in the toaster oven as in step 1, then pour soon after.

Lots of bubbles around the wood or embedded item

Almost always moisture too. Stabilizing doesn't fix it for good: the core of the wood is fine, but stabilized wood sitting out picks up surface moisture from the air. That's exactly where the bubbles show up, on the surface where the resin touches the wood. When I first started stabilizing, I thought I'd never have to worry about this again, and then it happened to me a couple of times.

Bubbles all through the resin, not just at the wood

With a pressure resin, you probably didn't get it under pressure in time. With a no-pressure resin, you may have worked too many bubbles in while mixing. If you've dried your wood properly and still get bubbles, then you know moisture isn't the cause.

Cheap epoxy stuck in a silicone mold

Two of my no-pressure epoxy batches stuck so hard that the resin pulled apart from itself and tore the mold. You shouldn't need mold release with silicone, and the same resin released fine from my HDPE molds. I'm not sure if it was small bubbles grabbing on or heat. Either way, it's another reason I use HDPE.

Colored specks in burl

If the wood is porous and not fully stabilized (some burls and buckeye burls do this), Alumilite gets into the pores, and dark dye shows up as specks. Stabilize the wood first, or use clear or a lighter, more transparent color.

Blank breaks or flies off the lathe

That happened to me with the Art 'n Glow (white) once it was off the tailstock. I'd slowed the lathe way down, and a piece still broke off and shot at me. The resin also got so hot that it stuck to the towel I'd wrapped around it to sand. I've done that plenty of times with Alumilite and wood without a problem. It didn't hurt, but you don't want anything coming off the lathe. A resin that's weak and doesn't handle heat isn't worth that risk.

Video: 7 Things I Wish I Knew Before Resin Casting Alumilite
7 Things I Wish I Knew Before Resin Casting Alumilite

FAQ

What's the best resin for pen blanks?

For me it's Alumilite, cast under pressure. It turns strong and clear. The cheap art epoxies I tested were more brittle and had trouble with heat on the lathe.

Can you use cheap Amazon epoxy for woodturning?

You can get it on the lathe and it can look nice, but I don't recommend it. It was weak, it got hot, and once the tailstock came off it went out of round and broke.

Do you need a pressure pot for epoxy?

These epoxies are sold as not needing pressure, but my batches without pressure came out full of bubbles. The ones under pressure came out much better.

Why does my resin have bubbles or a milky line around the wood?

Moisture, in most cases, even with stabilized wood. Dry it at 200°F in a toaster oven before casting: 15 to 20 minutes for stabilized wood, 30 to 40 minutes or more for unstabilized dense hardwood.

Do I need to let the wood cool after heating it?

No. It cools enough while you mix, and if it sits too long it starts picking up moisture again.

Can you pour Alumilite onto cured Alumilite?

Yes. Scuff the cured surface with sandpaper first, or the new layer won't bond well and can peel off on the lathe.

If you'd rather skip the casting and go straight to turning, these are cast in Alumilite with grapevine I stabilize with Cactus Juice first. My swirl grapevine blanks are below, along with the green apple grapevine hybrid blanks.

Products in this guide

← All guides